As an objection to Utilitarianism, some people say it is a god-less doctrine, because its moral foundation is the happiness if man, and not the will of God. Well, Mill begs to differ. He believes it's all about how you perceive God. Let's think: there are no "gods" that would want their people to be miserable. Because the meaning of utilitarianism is causing the greatest about of good for the greatest amount of people, he believes this doctrine is amongst the ones that are godly.
Not only is the doctrine godly sound, it is Christ-like as well. Though not all Christian principles cause the greatest about of happiness for the greatest amount of people, it was not intended to cause harm either. Take fornication for example. Most people believe it is okay, however the bible clearly tells us it is wrong. Although this principle does not cause people happiness, is it meant for the good of the greatest amount of people. It not only intends good for the people, it is good for the people. This is true whether they agree with it or not. Does that still follow the rules of Utilitarianism? Do you agree that it is directly related to Christianity, or do you believe the objection?
I believed Mill relates Utilitarianism to being God-like because he has a strong background to his belief in Christianity. I do believe it goes hand and hand with Christianity because most principles involved in this religion is for the greater good.
ReplyDeleteI think that just because premarital sex goes against basic Christian teachings, if it makes the people involved happy, it still follows the rule of utilitarianism. It is intended for the greater good of the people that are participating in the act. It does not follow Christianity, but I think it can still apply to utilitarianism.
ReplyDeleteI feel as self pleasing people we may see that our actions that are done for the "greater good" can be blinded by our biased views. We do not like suffering and will do anything to keep from suffering. So in some cases yes I think there is a connection but I would not agree that there is always. Our will is not always God's will. God would not want His people to suffer of course but life isn't akways easy. It won't always be happy. To learn and grow the hard way may be the only way for some.
ReplyDelete