In my
opinion, I believe that most humans, at least most Americans, in this day in
age are consequentialists. This means that most people judge whether or not an
action is moral based on what the consequences of the action end up being. I
believe this is true because ever since we were little, our parents and other
role models have always taught us to “think of the consequences” before acting
in a certain circumstance. We are always asked, even if the reason behind the
act appears to be good, “do you realize what your action could do if it goes
wrong?” In addition, I believe that children are punished by parents and
teachers based solely on the results of the action, no matter what the child
was attempting to do. If, for example, a child is trying to help one of his or her
classmates carry some paint, but then trips and spills the paint all over the floor
and another child. The teacher might not see everything that had happened and
the classmate that had the paint spilled on them might say that the kid did it
on purpose and, therefore, the child would be punished. Even though, the child’s
intention of helping his friend carry something was morally good, the result of
the action is what the teacher based the punishment on. This may especially
ring true with a wide variety of school suspensions are being handed out to
young children for seemingly miniscule reasons. This may not be the best
example of this, but it is all I can think of at the moment. I also believe this
is true because throughout main stream media, we tend to focus on the
consequences of actions, which, in turn, tends to sway the public opinion in a
certain way. Because of this, we often only see the bad consequences, thus
causing a tendency to think of the consequences of every action. All in all, I
think that we, for the most part, focus on the consequences of an action and
decide whether it is moral or not based on the results, no matter the
intention.
I agree with you and your suspension example is actually really good because teachers may have thought that sending a kid home might be a punishment because they think that suspending the kid brings the greatest good for the large amount of people by keeping the "trouble" maker at home.
ReplyDeleteI also agree how your example of suspension goes well with the idea of consequentialism. The example of the paint made me think of suspensions due to fights. The principal decides to look at the outcome and punish those who have done wrong without measuring if maybe one of them was bullied or hurt first. I think we look at consequences because it is what we actually see, and it is hard to determine what a person thinks before taking action.
ReplyDeleteI also agree how your example of suspension goes well with the idea of consequentialism. The example of the paint made me think of suspensions due to fights. The principal decides to look at the outcome and punish those who have done wrong without measuring if maybe one of them was bullied or hurt first. I think we look at consequences because it is what we actually see, and it is hard to determine what a person thinks before taking action.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your idea that most children are raised as consequentialists. Even today every decision I make I look at the good and bad consequences an try to make sure what I decide makes the most good. Being a consequentialists can be confusing at times. Especially when something you did only for the good goes wrong.
ReplyDeleteI would also agree. Wether we are stopping and thinking if the consequences or they are subconsciously already there being brought up without having to think about them they are there. If something is hot we don't touch it. When we turn on the stove we know not to touch because it'll burn but we don't stop and take a couple minutes to decide. But the consequences are already known. It is hard sometimes to figure out what kind of outcome some things will have but we live and learn.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your point of view, in which you state that what really matters for people is just the result of an action and not the intention. People don't only see the consequences, leaving aside with which purpose we did the action
ReplyDelete