When a person takes the action of
killing another human being, does that person deserve to continue living? If
not, do they need to be punished and “reformed”? What does that look like,
prison? Three square meals a day and having a roof over your head does not sound
like punishment for that level of crime. So would that mean that death is the
ultimate punishment? Many people would argue that death is too easy, or that is
not our place at all to sentence someone to death. However, by removing someone
from the earth that has willingly taken another human beings life, you are
insuring multiple things. First you are insuring that they cannot ever take the
life of another human being and that they no longer pose a threat to society.
Secondly, a standard is being set by saying that when a person chooses to kill
another person, that persons due punishment is death. Maybe this will not
always deter people from killing one another, but I can guarantee you that a
lot more killing would take place if there was no punishment whatsoever. The argument
many people use against capital punishment of “why do we kill to show killing
is wrong”, is weak because the one thing most people do not want to do, is die.
So by setting this standard, it not only shows how wrong murder is in the eyes
of the justice system, but it also hopes to make some would be killers think
twice before committing the act of murder.
Whichever side you choose, for or against
the death penalty, I think we can all agree that murder is wrong. Many grey
lines start popping up when dealing with drugs, alcohol, etc, both those are
all best left to be interpreted by individual cases.
Yes, I think we can definitely all agree that murder is wrong. But what is the definition of murder? Taking someone's life? If so, isn't killing someone for a crime murder?
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion capital punishment does not work because you really can't fully learn your lesson. You still will always have a choice afterwards on whether you are going to continue to do the right thing or not.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Solomon, capital punishment does nothing. You say nobody wants to die, but when you really think about it how many murderers and criminals risk their lives to commit the crime? They don't know if they person they are going to attack has a gun or weapon on them or if they are going to fight back.People who commit crimes don't value life anymore, they have no reason that's why they make these terrible decisions. So to say that telling a person with no reasoning skills that if they kill someone they might get caught and killed too is going to stop them from killing, that doesn't make much sense.
ReplyDelete